Essay on Moral Position - 1059 Words

Moral Position Dworkins moral position is reasons, foundation theory and self-evident. Moral position has to give good (articulate) reasons for moral position to be valid. Things like prejudices and emotions are not justifiable characteristics for a moral position. In Dworkins essay The Concept of a Moral Position, he elaborates on what a moral position really is, and what it isnt. Dworkin states that moral position cannot be based on prejudice or emotion. According to Websters dictionary, prejudice is the unreasonable feelings, opinions, or attitudes of a hostile nature regarding a racial, religious or national group. Therefore a person cannot judge another based on these grounds of prejudice or emotion. The example†¦show more content†¦For example, if a man would say I hate homosexuals that would be considered as his personal emotion because he gives no justified reason for his statement aside from pure fear or inferiority. Yet he is still entitled to his own opinion under the first amendment. If the same man would also give a reason for his prejudice such as I hate homosexuals, because Im afraid they might do something to me it is his own justifiable reason but it is only justified to him and not to anyone else. Hence, making his moral opinion only his own and not societies moral opinion and his moral position is wrong which must be rejected. Moral position cannot be based on the beliefs of others. By relying on others moral position a person shows that he doesnt have his own views and values on the subject, and therefore his or her position is unjustified. It is a form of the advice we are given by others of be a leader and not a follower. For example if I say that I dont like Russian people because no body else likes them. That statement would not be a justifiable argument for the sake of morality, it would just be a reason for myself, which lack supporting evidence. It would just show that I dont have or formed my own opinion, and therefore I cannot give a good enough reason to prove my position, hence making myShow MoreRelatedEthics, Morals, Law And Position Of Leader1827 Words   |  8 PagesEthics, morals, law and position of leader Ethic is a set of principles and philosophy that governs the thought process pertaining to conducts of people in diversified field. It could be science, civic society, law order, politics, diplomacy or any personal matter between two individuals. Moral is more to do with differentiating right from wrong, setting standard for oneself for best behavior and learning from the past experience and applying them in present to achieve sense of self belief andRead MoreThe Cuban Missile Crisis And Its Effect On The Moral Position Of The United States987 Words   |  4 Pageswas provided, the lies of Kruschev were exposed, and Robert Kennedy said, â€Å"I now know how Tojo felt when he was planning Pearl Harbor† (Kennedy, 25). John F. Kennedy needed to handle the presence of the Soviets in Cuba without diminishing the moral position of the United States. When a formal meeting of the National Security Council was held, many arguments were shared o how to handle the crisis. The main arguments of action were blockade or military action, in particular- nuclear weapons. â€Å"ItRead MoreRunning Head : Arguing A Moral Stance1269 Words   |  6 PagesARGUING A MORAL STANCE 1 Arguing a Moral Stance Dawn Phillips Patten University ARGUING A MORAL STANCE 2 Arguing a Moral Stance For a moment we can imagine two well qualified individuals interviewing on the same day for open positions as buyers for a major department store. They both hold college degrees, have similar work experience and both speak Spanish as a second language. They are both married, are the sole financial provider for their family, have one child and are home-owners. The positions areRead MoreAnalysis Of Mandevilles Travels And Bisclavret1423 Words   |  6 Pages Monsters have always fascinated readers because of their mysterious origins and motives. These strange and unknown characteristics lead us to ask questions and really think about how humans justify their actions and consider what is and isn’t moral. Monsters also help us come to a conclusion about who we are as people in a functioning society. In the works of Mandeville’s Travels and Bisclavret, the authors help us discover who we are to unify us as a community, give us a sense of security, andRead MoreHow Manh s Influence On The Classroom1267 Words   |  6 PagesGiang’s translation, Manh focuses on the phrase ‘in need’; he adds few more examples (in need of money, in need of motorbike) in order to better illustrate the usage and meaning of this phrase. However from line 88 to line 92, there is an implicit moral message conveyed by Manh. With discourse marker ‘so’ signifying a consequential relation between the present messages with t he prior context, Manh stresses on the importance of friend selection (â€Å"just consider†, line 88). Moreover, the use of â€Å"people†Read MorePeter Singer And John Arthur s Views On Famine And Affluence1451 Words   |  6 Pagessupply themselves beyond the essentials puts us in a position that can be disputed: should we supply for others who cannot attain basic elements for survival? In a piece by Peter Singer entitled, â€Å"Famine, Affluence, and Morality,† Singer argues that Americans should prevent atrocious situations to arise but, we also should not sacrifice something of equal importance while doing so. Moreover, in the piece by John Arthur, â€Å"World Hunger and Moral Obligation: The Case Against Singer,† Arthur disagreesRead More Garcia-Marquezs A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings Essay1006 Words   |  5 Pages..they had to call in troops...to disperse the mob that was about to knock the house down†(442). Elisenda’s conception of charging the inquisitive for a peek at the angel brought great wealth to the family. With this wealth Pelayo exchanges his position as bailiff, guarding dangerous criminals for that of running a rabbit warren, guarding the gentlest of creatures. Meanwhile, Elisenda becomes a lady of high social status. As days turn into years Pelayo and Elisenda accept the angel’s presenceRead MoreWhy Eating Meat is Morally Impermissible 1435 Words   |  6 Pagesaffordability of meat-based foods compared to vegetable-based foods and other factors like environmental moral code, culture, and religion. All these points are important in justifying whether humans are morally right when choosing to eat meat. This paper will argue that it is morally impermissible to eat meat by focusing on the treatment of animals, the environmental argument, animal rights, pain, morals, religion, and the law. Treatment of animals Vegetarians are uncomfortable with how humans treat animalsRead MoreKant s Moral Judgement Of Moral Luck1630 Words   |  7 PagesIntro to Philosophy 9 October 2015 â€Å"Kant believed that good or bad luck should influence neither our moral judgment of a person and his actions, nor his moral assessment of himself.† -Thomas Nagel Thomas Nagel, Professor of Philosophy at New York University developed the current philosophical idea of Moral luck. Kant denied the possibility of moral luck but Nagel created the idea of moral luck based on Kant’s opposition. As quoted above, Kant thought that luck should not be the basis of judgementRead MoreRelativism, By Rachel s And Williams Standpoint On Relativism1386 Words   |  6 Pagesfaced is whether or not there is a universal moral code all people can abide too? In explaining Rachel’s and Williams standpoint on Relativism and what they argue for, I on the other hand, will argue for relativism, in using some of Rachel’s views, in rejecting Williams conclusion of relativism. For Williams perceives no one outside of a society should impend on the social matters of a differing nation. To argue why his view is abstract, As well in many moral degrees, his philosophical conclusion could